First Choice Insurance Agency, Inc: Insurance in Lindenhurst,
West Babylon, Amityville, Copiague, and all of New York State.

Low rates, Low or NO deposit, E-Z payments, Instant coverage Auto Insurance for every driver, age & vehicle (Tickets, Accidents, Permits, Suspended Licenses OK)

We know you need affordable rates on quality insurance coverage, so we take the time to get to know you, your needs and to evaluate your circumstance before we offer or write a policy for you. At First Choice Insurance Agency, Inc., we make sure our products and services are right for your budget and easy for you to understand. It’s important to our professional agents to build relationships with you, offering accountability and availability every step of the way. As your needs evolve, your coverage requirements may change, and with an insurance partner like First Choice at your side, you can be confident you’ll have us to check that your policy is protecting you and your assets. With almost three decades of experience in personal and commercial insurance lines, we’re proud to be one of Long Island’s foremost independent insurance agencies. At First Choice Insurance, you’re our top priority!

Over 70% of our business is referrals…we must be doing something right!

Since 1987, First Choice Insurance Agency, Inc. has been providing clients and their families in the NYC area with world-class insurance service and products. Our clients are so satisfied with our insurance service and support that over 70% of our new clients are referred to us by them! We believe in offering old-fashioned service with modern convenience –so when you call, a person will always answer! We don’t use voice mail. We care about your property, about your business and about you.

We help you protect what matters most.

Helping you protect your family and your property is our main goal at First Choice Insurance. We all make investments that are important to us, whether it’s our homes that we live in, our cars that we drive, or the businesses we own. First Choice Insurance is here to provide you with the information you need and the insurance products you require, all at a competitive rate you can afford. You can enjoy the life you’ve worked so hard to achieve without concern.

Put our experience to work for you.

Our team of professionals will always have your priorities and best interests at heart when providing you with the specific insurance coverage you need, which is why we go the extra mile to design comprehensive insurance tailored to your situation. We have years of experience that we put to work for you, providing policies from trustworthy companies. As an independent agency, we’re able to do the comparison shopping for you, getting you the most competitive rates for the best coverage.

For Homeowners, Auto, and Business Insurance in the Long Island, New York City and NY State areas, Contact Us today!

  • Apartments
  • Auto
  • Boats
  • Bonds
  • Builder's Risk Insurance
  • Condos and Cooperatives
  • Errors & Omissions
  • Garage Liability
  • General Liability
  • Homes
  • Mechanic and Body Shop
  • Motorcycle
  • Personal Watercraft
  • Professional Liability
  • Rentals
  • RVs
  • Townhomes
  • Worker’s Compensation
  • ATVs / Off-road Vehicles
  • Cabs and Limousines
  • Classic Cars
  • Commercial Autos & Fleet
  • Commercial Property
  • Commercial Umbrella
  • Disability in Benefits Packages
  • Fire, Flood, and Waterfront
  • Homes under Construction
  • Jewelry, artwork, etc. (floater items)
  • Liquor Liability
  • Snowmobiles
  • Special Events
  • Trailers
  • Trucks and Vans
  • Umbrell
  • Vacant Homes