About Auto, Business, Flood, General Liability & Home Insurance from First Choice Insurance Agency: Serving Brooklyn, Queens, Jamaica, Amityville, Babylon, Deer Park, Farmingdale, Lindenhurst, Massapequa NY.

Three decades of service.

First Choice Insurance has been providing a full range of complete services for personal and commercial insurance since 1987. We can insure your home, your car, or your business without breaking your budget. Our professional insurance staff is experienced, licensed agents who understand the importance of the different kinds of coverage for your needs, how those needs adapt over time, and how your premiums fit in your budget.

Our clients believe in us!

At First Choice, 70% of our clients are referred – that means that most of our clients were referred to us by our other, very-satisfied clients! We believe in offering the best in outstanding products and services with a personal touch; we don’t use voice mail, so when you call, you will always speak with a person. With an insurance partner like First Choice on your side, you’ll always have a world-class policy protecting you and your assets, no matter how your coverage needs evolve over time. First Choice Insurance, with three decades of experience in personal and commercial lines, stands proud as one of Long Island’s premier independent insurance agencies. We care about you.

Protect your investment.

Our primary goal at First Choice Insurance is to help you protect your family your property and your business. We all make important investments in our lives and future, whether it’s our cars, our homes, or our company. First Choice Insurance can provide you with the information you need to make good choices about the coverage you require. Enjoy the life you’ve worked hard to make for yourself and your family by insuring your legacy against the risks you’ll face.

Independent insurance agency.

We are an independent insurance agency established nearly three decades ago to provide insurance products and services to our clients in Long Island and surrounding areas. You can be sure our professional team will always put you first when you’re searching for the appropriate coverage for your home, auto, or business. We can design a comprehensive insurance package for you that includes multiple policy discounts. We have the knowledge and experience to provide competitive rates on the top insurance products available.

For Homeowners, Auto, and Business Insurance in the Long Island, New York City and NY State areas, Contact Us today!

  • Apartments
  • Auto
  • Boats
  • Bonds
  • Builder's Risk Insurance
  • Condos and Cooperatives
  • Errors & Omissions
  • Garage Liability
  • General Liability
  • Homes
  • Mechanic and Body Shop
  • Motorcycle
  • Personal Watercraft
  • Professional Liability
  • Rentals
  • RVs
  • Townhomes
  • Worker’s Compensation
  • ATVs / Off-road Vehicles
  • Cabs and Limousines
  • Classic Cars
  • Commercial Autos & Fleet
  • Commercial Property
  • Commercial Umbrella
  • Disability in Benefits Packages
  • Fire, Flood, and Waterfront
  • Homes under Construction
  • Jewelry, Artwork, etc. (Floater Items)
  • Liquor Liability
  • Snowmobiles
  • Special Events
  • Trailers
  • Trucks and Vans
  • Umbrella
  • Vacant Homes